top of page

Legend of the Seas vs Star of the Seas: What's Actually Different?

Writer: The Walking Cruiser
The Walking Cruiser
Nov 14
4 min read
Legend of the Seas
Legend of the Seas

Legend of the Seas and Star of the Seas are sister ships built on the same Icon-class platform: the same 20 decks, the same eight neighbourhoods and the same 5,610 guests at double occupancy. The real differences are the supper club, the headline shows, one venue on the Royal Promenade and where each ship sails from. Book on itinerary and price, not on the hull.

I sailed Legend of the Seas in September 2026 on a Mediterranean week, and I have not sailed Star. So treat this as a Legend walkthrough set against Star's published line-up. Where I'm relying on Royal Caribbean's own information and not my own eyes, I say so.


Is Legend of the Seas bigger than Star of the Seas?

Barely. Legend is about a foot longer than Star and Icon, and all three share the same design. Star is listed at 248,663 gross tons, and Legend's figure is quoted slightly differently depending on where you look. None of it is anything you would notice on board. The deck plan, the cabins, the pools and the slides are the same ship.


Legend of the Seas vs Star of the Seas: the comparison table


Legend of the Seas

Star of the Seas

Debut

July 2026

August 2025

Size

Icon class, 20 decks, about a foot longer

Icon class, 20 decks, 248,663 GT

Guests

5,610 at double occupancy

5,610 at double occupancy

Neighbourhoods

Eight, same layout

Eight, same layout

Supper club

Hollywoodland Supper Club

Lincoln Park Supper Club

Headline theatre show

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

Back to the Future: The Musical

Royal Promenade venue

Royal Railway, Legend Station

The Attic comedy club

Chief Dog Officer

Skipper

Sailor

Home port

Mediterranean in summer 2026, Fort Lauderdale from November 2026

Port Canaveral (Orlando)

Best for

Europe, or the newest dining

A Caribbean week with Orlando before or after


Which ship has the better dining?

It comes down to two venues. Both ships have a supper club, a long sit-down dinner with live music built into it, priced as a premium extra. On Star it's the Lincoln Park Supper Club, themed on 1930s Chicago with live jazz. On Legend it's the Hollywoodland Supper Club, themed on the golden age of Hollywood. I've covered that one in full in my Hollywoodland Supper Club review.

The bigger difference is Royal Railway, Legend Station. It's a dining room built as a train carriage, where the windows are screens and the scenery moves past while you eat. Star does not have it. On Star, that spot on the Royal Promenade is The Attic, a comedy club. So Legend gains a restaurant and loses a comedy venue, and which of those you'd miss more is your call.

The included food is the same on both: main dining room, Windjammer, Sorrento's and the rest. If you're not planning to pay for speciality dining, there is very little between them.


Which ship has the better shows?

Different, not better. Star's headline is Back to the Future: The Musical in the Royal Theater, with Torque in the AquaDome and Sol on the ice rink. Legend's headline is Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, alongside America's Got Talent LIVE, Shockwave in the AquaTheater and Fusion.

For most adults, Back to the Future is the bigger name. With young children, Charlie is the easier sell. That's taste and not quality, and the theatres, the ice rink and the AquaDome are identical on both ships. Book your shows in the app as soon as your window opens, whichever ship you choose.


Where does each ship sail?

This is the difference that should decide it. Star of the Seas sails 7-night Eastern and Western Caribbean round trips from Port Canaveral, an hour from Orlando, and each one includes a day at Perfect Day CocoCay.

Legend of the Seas spent her first summer in the Mediterranean, sailing from Rome (Civitavecchia) and Barcelona, which is where I joined her. She moved to Fort Lauderdale in November 2026 for Caribbean sailings.

So if you want theme parks either side of your cruise, that's Star. If you want the ship in Europe, it was only ever Legend.


Which ship is cheaper?

Fares move every week, so I won't quote a number that will be wrong by the time you read this. When I checked comparison sites in November 2026, Star's lead-in fares were below Legend's, which is what you'd expect: the newest ship usually carries a premium in her first year. Price the same week on both before you decide.


So which one should you book?

  • Book Legend of the Seas if you want Royal Railway, you've already seen Star's shows, or her itinerary suits you better.

  • Book Star of the Seas if you want to pair the cruise with Orlando, you want Back to the Future, or she is cheaper for your week.

  • Don't pay extra for either just because she is newer. They are the same ship with a different menu and a different show.

For more on the ship I sailed, see my Legend of the Seas guide and Legend of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas.


Frequently asked questions

Is Legend of the Seas bigger than Star of the Seas?

Only by about a foot in length. Both are Icon-class ships with 20 decks, eight neighbourhoods and 5,610 guests at double occupancy, so you will not notice a size difference on board.


What does Legend of the Seas have that Star of the Seas does not?

Royal Railway, Legend Station, the Hollywoodland Supper Club, and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory as the headline theatre show.


What does Star of the Seas have that Legend of the Seas does not?

Back to the Future: The Musical, the Lincoln Park Supper Club and The Attic comedy club on the Royal Promenade.


Where does Star of the Seas sail from?

Star of the Seas sails 7-night Eastern and Western Caribbean round trips from Port Canaveral, near Orlando, with a stop at Perfect Day CocoCay.


Where does Legend of the Seas sail from?

Legend of the Seas spent her first summer in the Mediterranean, sailing from Rome (Civitavecchia) and Barcelona, and moved to Fort Lauderdale in November 2026.


Should I book Legend of the Seas or Star of the Seas?

Book on itinerary and price. The ships are near-identical, so pick the home port and week that suit you, and treat the different shows and restaurants as a tie-breaker.


Watch the full Legend of the Seas tour on The Walking Cruiser YouTube channel.

Allure of the Seas cruise ship sailing at sea

Newsletter

New ship tours, straight to your inbox.

One email when a new tour, guide or big cruise story goes live. No spam.

bottom of page